Question 1

What is the question of the Gemara on our Mishna?

Accepted Answer

Why does the Mishna switch from Jug to Barrel

Answer

Why does the Braissa mention honey?

Answer

Why is the guy who broke the barrel Chayiv?

Answer

When is snack time?

Question 2

What is the answer of Rav Pappa?

Accepted Answer

The word Kad is Interchangeable with Chavis

Answer

Rav Pappa asks a question he doesnt have an answer

Answer

The Mishna isnt so specific with its wording

Question 3

What is the Gemara's inquiry about Rav Pappa's answer?

Accepted Answer

Lemai Nafka Mina? How does the fact that the words are interchangeable make any difference in Halacha? Who cares that they are interchangeable

Answer

If Kad and Chavis are interchangeable, how will anyone buy a barrel, they'll always get a jug?

Answer

What planet are you from? A jug and Barrel are not interchangeable

Question 4

What is the Gemara's answer to the inquiry of Lemai Nafka Minah?

Accepted Answer

the fact that the words are interchangeable matters in cases of buying and selling

Answer

it docent matter there just interchangeable because they are

Answer

Rabbi i need another snack

Answer

for barrel rolling contests

Question 5

What's the Gemara's question of הכי דמי - אילימא?

Accepted Answer

What situation of buying and selling are you referring to? If you're suggesting that he's its in a location where everyone calls Kad a Kad and Chavis a Chavis, how can we say that the words can be interchangeable when buying a selling?

Answer

Why doesnt this guy just demand a refund?

Answer

Who would buy from someone that docent know what a barrel is?

Question 6

What is the Gemara's answer of לא צריכה?

Accepted Answer

No, This teaching that its interchangeable is needed in a location where most people DONT mix up jug and barrel but SOME do.

Answer

this whole law isnt needed

Answer

We need this law to teach that in a place where everyone mixes up jug and barrel there are no refunds on any containers since we never know what anyone means anyways

Question 7

What is the מהו דתימה (What would I assume?)of the Gemara's answer

Accepted Answer

Since MOST people mean Barrel when they say Barrel we should go based on the majority and assume that the buyer meant jug when he said jug and the seller must give him the barrel.

Answer

we should split the money in half

Answer

we should follow the minority and make the buyer take the jug

Question 8

What is the Ka Mashma Lan (what the Mishna and Rav Pappa come to teach us)

Accepted Answer

You would think we decide what the buyer meant based on MAJORITY, Rav Pappa and our Mishna come to each us that no, when buying and selling even when there is only a minority that mix up Jug and Barrel we DONT decide money mater based on MAJORITY. Rather a proof must be presented to get the money back from the seller.

Answer

Wait you mean to tell me that just by the Mishna switching a word the Gemara is gonna eanr such a huge idea about when we follow Majority?

Answer

Money cases always follows the Majority no matter what

Related quizzes

Related quizzes